The gaps

What we don't know

The record is full of holes. This page leaves them open. A blank frame is not a face, and a dramatised scene is not a document.

193

No portrait in this register

Blank cameos, not invented likenesses

16

Age not recorded

Of the women in the register

82

No death recorded

6 other dates are marked uncertain

54

No later trace here

No death and no record of leaving the colony

Birthplaces, voices, fates

  • Birthplace is not a field in the University of Wollongong database this register uses. Trial place is not birthplace, and it is not treated as one.
  • Their own words are not in this register. Where the database quotes a trial, the quotation is not copied, because several of those notes are cut off in the published spreadsheet.
  • 82 women have no death recorded here. 6 have a date the database itself queries. 54 have neither a death nor a note that they left the colony.
  • Bowes Smyth left offices blank: the surveyor general appears as a dash, and so does the provost martial. Those names are not filled in.

Documented, or dramatised

The register and the officers are documents: a database field, or a line in Arthur Bowes Smyth's journal, with the source named.

The Stranger's Case and The Price of Bread are dramatised. The Woman Who Stole Bread is a composite character, inspired by real women such as Elizabeth Pulley. She is not a single documented person, and she is not identified with any woman in the register. Elizabeth Pulley, whose theft of food is the real case behind that story, sailed on the Friendship and the Prince of Wales, not the Lady Penrhyn.

The Hall of Stories·The register·Sources

Counts that do not agree

On 22 March 1787 Bowes Smyth wrote that the Lady Penrhyn had 109 female convicts and 8 children. The Wollongong database lists 102 women for that ship. He wrote 50 women on the Prince of Wales, 20 on the Charlotte, and 100 men and women together on the Friendship. The database lists 50, 20 and 21 women on those ships. A State Library classroom page has said the Prince of Wales carried 49 women. This site shows both kinds of number and does not pretend they are the same count.